Guiding our future generations is a big task. Today’s youngest children will grow up in a world we could never even imagine, here are some tips for instilling the emotional tools and grit needed for them to tackle the world’s problems! The following article is based on ways to correct real, not ideal, behaviors observed by teachers working in daycares. This article is a guide; you can skip around and use as many tips as you want.
Avoid singling out “troublemakers.” It is okay, of course, to tell a child not to do something if they break the rules or do something morally wrong. Consequences for actions are an excellent tool for teaching respect and responsibility. However, after the punishment, there is no need to bring up how “bad” the child is later when the child is no longer doing what led to the consequence.
Why This Works
Recent research shows preschoolers can feel shame as early as two or three. Feelings of shame are linked to feelings of depression in preschoolers. This shame can have lifelong implications as the preschool years lay the groundwork for kindergarten. Habits are hard-wired into a child’s brain as young as preschool; if not addressed, they can stay with a child for life. We all know how difficult it is to think clearly and learn when feeling shame. We have all been there. So why not start children off ready to respect themselves and, therefore, have greater respect for others and their community?
Play with, cuddle, and redirect crying children. I have seen teachers say things like “all done,” “no thank you,” and “it’s not all about you” to a crying child, and every time I saw someone do this, it only seemed to make the children cry more. When you do say something, try empathizing with the child. You could say something like, “Hi Tommy, are you sad because you miss your mama? Yeah, that’s hard (pause, hold the child, rock them side to side.) I promise we’re safe here, though. So let’s look out the window together.” Try bringing them to a window to look out of and talk gently in a soft voice or play together with a special toy that they can only play with when they’re upset. It does not matter your exact words because if you speak from the heart, the child will at least understand your tone. Use this tone with older children as well. Sometimes with an older child, you may need to say, “can you use your words and tell me what’s wrong?” then empathize with the child. These are some of many examples of emotionally responsible caregiving.
Why This Works
In guiding future generations, emotionally responsive caregiving helps mediate the effects of high-risk environments. Everyone wants to be heard, but why is being heard such a powerful tool for emotionally responsive caregiving? Because a child’s brain is already forming the connections for learning, social skills, emotional resilience, and even the ability to concentrate, focus, and prioritize tasks. For example, if a child is constantly distressed, they cannot learn the skills needed to be a functional adult. Have you ever felt like you communicated something, someone understood what you were saying and then responded with just the right thing? Then you know what a huge relief it is. Imagine you are a young child and say something similar, and the same person tells you to be quiet. So, you would probably be frustrated and get even more upset.
Never punish children by taking away recess time, especially with challenging children, because they need it the most!
Why This Works
If you work with or have kids, you know they need to play, but unstructured play outdoors is essential for a child’s ability to learn. According to recent research, there is a strong link between physical fitness and cognitive performance in preschoolers. What better place to run around than the great outdoors! According to a study by the Extreme Psychology and Medicine journal, time spent outside helps with stress reduction, mental fatigue, mood, self-esteem, and perceived health, especially for small children!
Future generations, in many ways, have odds stacked against them, and health will be essential. With young children, sometimes it’s just easier to give them something that you know they will eat than to provide them with a fruit or vegetable and watch it sit on their plate until it ends up in the trash. Unfortunately, though, this is doing more harm than good.
Why This Works
Thankfully, children generally don’t starve themselves! For the first couple meals, if you only give the child a vegetable and main course, with no third option on their plate, at first, they might be a little hungry if they don’t like it, maybe even very hungry. But they will try it sooner or later, and YUCK will eventually become a YUM! It’s true; it’s hard to see their little faces light up at a third preferred option. So, while this might be a quick fix, the more you give a child a third option, the less likely they will eventually try the broccoli. Soon broccoli will always be a YUCK!
You can teach independence as early as the toddler years! Heaven knows our future generations will need to be independent. You can start by encouraging cleaning-up behaviors in toddlers who are not yet old enough to speak! However, there is a method to the madness. Don’t yell, “No, thank you! Look, clean up! Clean up now!” to get a toddler to clean up. They will most likely get embarrassed and not even realize why they are in trouble. Making a mess for them was fun, so there is no value in cleaning up. They may even act out and make more messes in the future.
Instead, try saying something like, “Wow, look at all these toys! Do you think you could show me where this one goes?” Then, hand each child a toy, one at a time. Each time they are successful, try saying something like, “Good job.” Suppose they are very young and still don’t understand. In that case, you could show them by placing a toy in the correct spot or using the hand-over-hand method, then letting them eventually do it themselves.
Why This Works
Parents need a little help too! Wouldn’t it be lovely to teach our future generations to clean early on? Also, as an adult, you could be the most intelligent, most determined person in the world. However, without knowing how to organize your time, priorities, and environment, you will still need a ton of help. These skills are called scaffolding and are a way to organize your time and environment to fit your needs. The technical term is executive functioning. With the invention of cell phones, children live in an age of constant distraction, and executive functioning skills are now becoming more critical than ever! So, what is one of the best ways to teach executive functioning? Start young when children’s brains are still malleable, and learning is easy!
Try to distract and redirect toddlers who are not sharing by bringing over another toy or distracting them, but model kindness. Do not yell at them for not sharing. Toddlers do not yet understand that other toddlers have needs other than their own, so to the toddler, it feels like you are yelling at them for no reason. This yelling teaches the toddlers that it is okay to yell at another person for no reason (even though you’re not yelling at them for no reason.)
Why This Works
No one likes hearing a toddler throwing a tantrum (most of the time, it’s unavoidable), but sharing tantrums is avoidable! Learning to get along with other children for the first time is stressful at first. Realizing that other children have different points of view is a HUGE developmental milestone and can take a very long time! They will learn this skill eventually but being yelled at and then having a toy taken away doesn’t make it go any faster. This skill can be more difficult for children with special needs. It’s stressful for both the child and the caretaker. Learning this skill can be encouraged in three-year-olds and older through turn-taking, unstructured play, reading stories, and talking about the child’s emotions and the emotions of yourself or other children. Unfortunately, a study published in “Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development” suggests that understanding different points of view may not fully occur in our future generations until age six or seven.
Lift Them Up
Children understand more than we think. So why not start them off with loving, encouraging, warm language that lifts them up instead of tears them down? Do you ever remember as a child loving someone who called you bad, or a troublemaker, or a brat, or spoiled? Hopefully not, but it does happen.
Why This Works
Have you ever heard of the labeling theory? It’s a real thing and applies to our future generations too. Always referring to a child negatively while their brains are still developing will feed how the child thinks of him or herself. So be careful of the language you use around children. If you constantly embarrass them, say negative things, and yell at them for not doing what you want. Chances are you will get lots of “NO!” in return, and the child may even go out of their way not to please you. The more positive things you say, the more they will want to please you, and the more they will act the way you describe them. If you say “Wow, what a good helper” a lot, chances are that child will go out of their way to be helpful. If you say I’m so proud of you, that child will find ways to make you proud. Toddlers are much more likely to respond to positive feedback than negative. According to a Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review study, positive feedback is MORE effective at discouraging bad behavior than negative feedback. Tell your child how much you appreciate when they did the right thing, instead of only mentioning it when they act up. Be sure to tell them how happy these positive behaviors make you. The bottom line is to love your child, and they will love you right back!
Barrett KC, Cole PM, Zahn-Waxler C. Avoiders versus amenders: Implications for the investigation of guilt and shame during toddlerhood? Cognition and Emotion. 1993;7:481–505
Egeland, B., Carlson, E., & Sroufe, L. (1993). Resilience as process. Development and Psychopathology, 5(4), 517-528. doi:10.1017/S0954579400
Fabricius, W.V., Gonzales, C.R., Pesch, A., Weimer, A.A., Pugliese, J., Carroll, K., Bolnick, R.R., Kupfer, A.S., Eisenberg, N. and Spinrad, T.L. (2021), Perceptual Access Reasoning (PAR) in Developing a Representational Theory of Mind. Monographs Society Res Child, 86: 7-154. https://doi.org/10.1111/mono.12432
Gladwell, V.F., Brown, D.K., Wood, C. et al. The great outdoors: how a green exercise environment can benefit all. Extrem Physiol Med 2, 3 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1186/2046-7648-2-3
Luby, J., Belden, A., Sullivan, J., Hayen, R., McCadney, A. and Spitznagel, E. (2009), Shame and guilt in preschool depression: evidence for elevations in self-conscious emotions in depression as early as age 3. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 50: 1156-1166. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7610.2009.02077.x
Owen, D. J., Slep, A. M. S., & Heyman, R. E. (2012). The effect of praise, positive nonverbal response, reprimand, and negative nonverbal response on child compliance: A systematic review. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 15(4), 364-385. doi:10.1007/s10567-012-0120-0